Cilmeron's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Gone Fishing?]

okay.. for your first one not bad

The drawing was not that good at all but not too bad.
No preloader no play button no stop.. very bad.
The idea is.. bad.
The music is ok but not too innovative.
It's not really funny and it's damn short.
More like a bad music video than a good flash movie.
But as you wrote it's your first animation (if that's right) I have to bow ;) Keep on and I'm sure you'll get big some day (Or you'll going down the water pipe *muahahaha.. cough*)

[One Pie to Rule Them All]

o_O

First of all.. the flash - or better said it's art/sound was much like legendaryfrogs one ring to rule them all saga.. just not even half as good of course..
Second point: It's Sméagol not Smeagol or Smeagal -.-
It was not as funny as I first thought it would be. But the idea is nice. The Soundtrack is not bad but for a lotr flash I suggest to use lotr music (leonard rosenman's soundtrack he wrote for lotr animated per example, or (of course) howard shore's soundtrack for the lotr trilogy)
So my facit: Not bad but not worth to get 5 out of 5 points (it's more like a 3) :P

[Plans to Fuck Alexis 6]

generaly I liked it

The idea is not bad. It's quite funny.. the drawings are quite good and the team america song is greeeeat ;)
Keep on with that stuff.

Ryan-Smith responds:

we will thanks.

[count dashlua]

not that funny

the drawing was nice. the animation was quite good but the storyline is crap.. it was way too short and I missed a play button at the beginning. keep on and get better...

[German webcomic funtime!]

too short

Would be very good if it'd last more than this few words. A whole comic episode per example :D The idea itself is great.. hrhr meatelerdey..